"The Balance Sheet & the Possible Largest Risk to the Financial Markets"
Prior to diving into, what we believe is the largest risk to markets, Let’s set the stage first…
In the past few weeks we have seen a steeper deterioration in markets as CPI data came in slightly higher than expected. On September 13th, 2022 the S&P 500 had its largest 1 day drop since 2020, ending the day lower by -4.32%. The data discovered that food and rent costs seem to be the culprit to the elevated prices. Once this occurred, rates such as the 2 Year T-Notes spiked to 3.75% from 3.58% just 24 hours prior (that’s a large move and remember on January 1st, the 2 Year Notes were returning 0.78%, yikes whoever is bullish on bonds prices). In addition to this, the yield curve inverted even further. This is not ideal for banks since this is how they make their money.
What and why do we care about the “Yield Curve”? Inversion of the Yield Curve…? Now you lost me…
Let’s break it out since it will be worth noting for future reference. A bank serves 2 primary functions in our world:
Savings or to hold our hard-earned money somewhere safe.
Trade Off
Pro: Keeps our cash liquid or ready to deploy at any time for living expenses, discretion spending or investing.
Con: Earns the lowest possible amount of interest while not being used. (Usually marked near short term rates) *But that is the price you pay to keep the funds in accessible at any time or in liquid form.
Secondly, to Borrow funds in the form of a loan.
Trade Off
Pro: Allows us to use the funds for any type of purpose and essentially “leverages” our own money (aka equity) above what we have, to be able to purchase items we would not able to afford
An simple example, a house.
Con: Pay Interest on the borrowed funds from the bank (Usually the rate could be marked slightly above a Treasury Note (bond) that has a similar time duration until maturity.
Essentially if you take out a car loan for 5 years, you may be paying slightly above a 5 Year Treasury Note (depending upon your credit score of course!)
So, how a bank makes money is by receiving more interest from loans, than what they are paying to savers in the form of interest.
Profit & Interest Rate Spread = Interest Received (from a loan to customers) – Interest Paid to Savers
Ultimately, if the Bank starts paying savers more interest than what they are receiving from their customers loans…then banks have a problem. Important note, that the banking system is not quite 1 for 1, or for every $1 in savings, they have $1 in loans, yet it can still pose serious problems if the yield curve continues to further invert.
Inversion of the yield curve = Interest Received – Interest Paid to Savers
[Example of inversion or Negative Net Interest Rate Margin: -1% = 5% Interest Received – 6% Interest Paid to Savers]
Again, the yield curve is not something we should just disregard as this plays a factor into what we believe is the largest risk to the markets.
So, what do we believe is the largest risk to the markets? Liquidity Risk
…or removal of cash out of the financial markets. This is set to begin in September as the Fed will begin the “Tightening” process.
What is liquidity risk?
It is a certain type of risk that creates excessive volatility due to the lack of capital (money) coming into the financial markets. Simply ask yourself, how does a market stay elevated? Simply put, it is the perception of what buyers are willing to pay for an asset, but what if buyers start running out of capital to invest in? How can you support prices with out capital? And lastly, why are we thinking that this could be a risk at all? It all pinpoints to the amount of cash the Fed has injected into banks starting as early as 2008.
Let’s fast forward and review the past Fed’s Policy since 2020…
The Fed purchased Treasury Bills, Notes, Bonds & MBS’s (see definitions below) from commercial banks.
Pro: Adds cash to commercial banks; elevates the cash reserves
Analogy: think of filling up your car’s gas tank with fuel; the more fuel the farther you can drive. The more cash, the more banks can lend.
Con: Can lead to inflation if there is too much credit or loans outstanding in the economy while supply of goods and services are limited due to the lack of labor.
Secondly, the Fed artificially pushed the Treasury prices higher which in turn lowered the yields or rates inversely. (Further explanation: Coupon payments or interest payments stay the same as the prices of the bonds increase, diluting the return. Similar to dividend yields moving lower as the price of stock moves higher)
Pro:Equity prices traded all time high levels. Why? Capital rotated from stocks to bonds since investors need a return on their investment. The bond market is not providing a sufficient yield so why be invested in the bond market.
Con: Artificially pushed speculative asset classes to new highs along with creating overvalued companies within the entire equity markets.
2021 Results of these actions were many but the most eye-opening was:
M2 Money Supply increased +$6.3Trillion while the Fed added $4.7T in excess cash reserves in the exact same time frame.
(Another term? Yes, another term to know; M2 stands for liquid cash that resting in current checking, savings, and other very liquid instruments such as money market funds which could be held by banks or brokerages. This does not include cash in retirement accounts.)
(WALCL: Federal Reserve Balance Sheet) (GDP: Gross Domestic Product) (M2SL: M2 Money Supply)
Now, no one is arguing that more cash is a bad thing, but it is under our belief that with the lack of labor and excess cash at everyone’s disposal is what lead to a multi-decade record of 9% inflation rate per annum. Now that inflation has risen substantially and no longer carries the assumption of being “transitory” or temporary, the Fed needs to pump the brakes on the inflow of money through asset purchases, which raises the level of systemic liquidity risk.
Let me give a visual on how liquidity works in the system. Very much as oil provides a lubricant to a car’s engine, the inflow of liquidity acts as an agent to keep markets functioning properly. If you drain oil from a car’s engine you run the risk of an engine block seizure. If you drain liquidity from the markets, buyers and sellers become more erratic due to not having as much cash on hand to purchase securities. To put it simply, if your credit card limit gets cut in half, you do not have as much capital to use for purchases, therefore limits the amount of capital flowing into the economy, therefore reduces the ability to keep markets elevated.
How can you really assume this you say? Well let’s look at the correlation of GDP versus the stimulus the Fed created post pandemic, or early 2020.
Last example, remember the Flash Crash of May 2010? I am not proposing that we are going to have a flash crash, but this is a representation of liquidity being removed from the financial system.
During this event, a young trader began “spoofing” the market, or removing bid orders within the S&P 500 Mini Futures markets, which triggered several stop orders executions creating a cascading sell off in the amount of near 10% within of 45 minutes. Keep in mind that market functionality and the economy are still 2 different worlds, both correlated to each other but separate real-world entities.
Ultimately, cash and liquidity flows are the sustaining lifeblood to all tradeable markets.
In conclusion, you may be asking yourself, well how will markets look moving forward? Of course, we and no one has the crystal ball, yet if we take a step back and ask ourselves a few questions?
1 How much of the market move is based upon an artificial price manipulation within the credit markets that were created by the fed?
2 Will the Fed give in and start asset repurchases again if volatility within markets gets unbearable?
3 How does the economy increase liquidity over time?
These types of questions seemingly point to a negative bias or outcome of financial markets. It is important that we are not proposing a crash or whatsoever, but we do believe that if the fed stays on course with raising rates, and tightening credit conditions, the U.S. equity markets may have a very tough time pushing higher in the future.
Sneak peek into our last segment…
In our final segment we will be reviewing a very thought-provoking set of circumstances when it comes to the future of our US markets. This involves population growth in the last 120 years, college versus trade school (the new white collar), and life after the baby-boomer generation.
A final question for you to ponder for the many who think markets will always go up over time…Are markets truly driven up by valuations or is it a mere supply of excess money driven by an increased population since the early 1900’s? What will happen once our population starts to decrease due to a lack of re-population? Ultimately, we do not know what will happen as Fiscal policy could change radically, but there are strong correlations we will examine in the final part 3 of the Fed versus Inflation.
Sign up for to receive our monthly fact sheet performance numbers in addition to our quick market commentary.
Disclosure:
IvyLine Capital Group, LLC(the “Company”) is exempt from registration as an investment adviser under state and federal law and only represents a single private investment vehicle. The Company is located in Pennsylvania. Company and its representatives are in compliance with the current filing requirements. Company may only engage in business in those states in which it is registered, or qualifies for an exemption or exclusion from registration requirements. Company’s web site is limited to the dissemination of general information pertaining to its advisory services. Accordingly, the publication of Company’s web site on the Internet should not be construed by any investor or client as Company’s solicitation to effect, or attempt to effect transactions in securities, or the rendering of personalized investment advice for compensation. Any future, direct communication by Company with a prospective investor shall be conducted by a representative that qualifies for an exemption or exclusion from registration in the state where the prospective client resides. Please remember that different types of investments involve varying degrees of risk, and there can be no assurance that the future performance of any specific investment or investment strategy (including those undertaken or recommended by Company), will be profitable or equal any historical performance level(s).